Seismic performance and strain localization in a historic masonry minaret: A comparative evaluation of internal steel strengthening strategies
Abstract
In this study, the seismic performance of a historic masonry minaret was investigated through nonlinear time-history analyses, and the relationship between global stiffness enhancement and local strain localization was evaluated. Four different internal steel strengthening scenarios, developed within a finite element model constructed by jointly considering experimental studies conducted on similar stone specimens and parameter ranges proposed in the literature, were comparatively analyzed under three distinct ground motion records. The modal analysis results indicated that the natural frequencies increased significantly in all strengthening scenarios, demonstrating a substantial improvement in overall structural stiffness. However, nonlinear dynamic analyses revealed that an increase in stiffness does not necessarily lead to an improvement in seismic performance. Displacement–time histories showed that the onset of instability was delayed in certain strengthening configurations; nevertheless, none of the interventions was able to completely prevent global collapse. The maximum principal strain distributions demonstrated that the collapse behavior was governed by tensile-dominated strain localization developing at the shaft–substructure transition region. In particular, strengthening configurations exhibiting partial continuity were found to induce stiffness discontinuities that could trigger early instability. The results indicate that the seismic performance of masonry minarets is closely related not only to global stiffness enhancement but also to the tensile strength, damage-softening characteristics, and energy dissipation capacity of the material. The study provides significant implications for performance-based strengthening design of masonry structures with cultural heritage value.
Keywords
References
ACI 440.1R-06 (2006). Guide for the Design and Construction of Structural Concrete Reinforced with FRP Bars. American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI, USA.
AFAD (2026). Turkish Accelerometric Database and Analysis System (TADAS). Disaster and Emergency Management Authority, Ankara, Türkiye, https://tadas.afad.gov.tr [accessed 06-02-2026].
ANSYS (2024). Ansys Academic Research Mechanical, Release 2024 R2, Help System. ANSYS, Inc., Canonsburg, PA, USA.
Ayvaz Y (1992). Parametric Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Slabs Subjected to Earthquake Excitation. Ph.D. dissertation, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA.
Bartoli G, Betti M, Borri C (2015). Numerical modeling of the structural behavior of Brunelleschi’s Dome of Santa Maria del Fiore. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 9(4), 408-429.
Bayraktar A, Hökelekli E (2021). A cost-effective FRCM technique for seismic strengthening of minarets. Engineering Structures, 229, 111672.
Binda L, Saisi A, Tiraboschi C (2000). Investigation procedures for the diagnosis of historic masonries. Construction and Building Materials, 14(4), 199-233.
Bozkurt E (2001). Neotectonics of Turkey-a synthesis. Geodinamica Acta, 14(1-3), 3-30.
CEN (2005). Eurocode 6: Design of Masonry Structures - Part 1-1: General Rules for Reinforced and Unreinforced Masonry Structures (EN 1996-1-1). European Committee for Standardization, Brussels, Belgium.
Colak Demirel BB, Yardimci YC, Kurucay HN (2024). Seismic behavior analysis of a 14th century Anatolian Seljuk Kumbet. Buildings, 14(12), 3921.
Cook RD, Malkus DS, Plesha ME (1989). Concepts and Applications of Finite Element Analysis. 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, USA.
Corradi M, Sisti R, Borri A (2018). Effect of thin cement-based renders on the structural response of masonry wall panels. Applied Sciences, 8(1), 98.
Çavuşlu M, Ülger T (2025). Seismic failure assessment of a 19th-century masonry minaret with and without iron clamp and dowel retrofit: experimental testing, ambient vibration validation and numerical modeling. Engineering Failure Analysis, 182, 110006.
Çelik A, Kocaman İ, Mercimek Ö, Anıl Ö, Fener M, Çelik B, Milani G (2025). Understanding roots of failure of historical Ottoman monumental buildings by means of advanced finite element modelling: the effect of the 1939 Erzincan earthquake on Nafiz Pasha Bath-house and Izzet Pasha Mosque. Engineering Failure Analysis, 169, 109811.
Çelik Z, Turan E, Oltulu M, Öner G (2024). Reinforcement of concrete beams using waste carbon-nanoclay-fiberglass laminate pieces. Challenge Journal of Concrete Research Letters, 15(1), 1-6.
Ergün M, Tayfur B (2024). Evaluation of the seismic performance pre- and post-restoration of a masonry clock tower's FE model updated via experimental and optimization methods. Engineering Failure Analysis, 158, 107986.
Ferrante A, Giordano E, Clementi F, Milani G, Formisano A (2021). FE vs. DE modeling for the nonlinear dynamics of a historic church in Central Italy. Geosciences, 11(5), 189.
Hotta H, Tsunoda T (2004). An experimental study on influence of mullion-type wall of predominant bending failure in reinforced concrete frame. In: Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Urban Earthquake Engineering, Yokohama, Japan, pp. 105-111.
ICOMOS (2003). Principles for the Analysis, Conservation and Structural Restoration of Architectural Heritage. International Council on Monuments and Sites, Paris, France.
Jadallah M, Alghamri R, Doğangün A (2025). Seismic retrofitting of the historic Şirvani Mosque using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP): a case study. Engineering Failure Analysis, 168, 109898.
Kahraman Y, Cakir F, Zulfikar AC, Gundogdu Gok M (2026). Seismic hazard and risk analyses of historical masonry structures in Kocaeli, Türkiye. Challenge Journal of Structural Mechanics, 12(1), 1-21.
Kara AF, Cakir F, Calis M (2025). Effect of elevated temperatures on mechanical properties of hydraulic lime-based mortar in historical structures. Challenge Journal of Structural Mechanics, 11(4), 184-200.
Karaton M, Çanakçı K (2020). Micro model analysis of JD6 and JD7 Eindhoven walls with fixed smeared crack model. Journal of Structural Engineering & Applied Mechanics, 3(1), 18-24.
Kaushik HB, Rai DC, Jain SK (2007). Stress-strain characteristics of clay brick masonry under uniaxial compression. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 19(9), 728-739.
Khalbous A, Bekdaş G, Nigdeli SM, Kayabekir AE (2026). Optimal metaheuristic design of CFRP wrapping for enhancing the shear capacity of reinforced concrete columns. Challenge Journal of Structural Mechanics, 12(1), 55-64.
Kiral A, Ergün M, Tonyali Z, Artar M, Şentürk İ (2024). A case study comparing seismic retrofitting techniques for a historically significant masonry building’s minaret. Engineering Failure Analysis, 166, 108873.
Kocaman İ, Kazaz İ, Okuyucu D (2018). Tarihi Erzurum Yakutiye Medresesi’nin yapısal davranışının incelenmesi. Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Mühendislik Fakültesi Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi, 20(58), 36-51. (in Turkish)
Kocaman İ (2023). The effect of the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes (Mw 7.7 and Mw 7.6) on historical masonry mosques and minarets. Engineering Failure Analysis, 149, 107225.
Kocaman İ, Gürbüz M (2023). Collapse mechanism of narthex part of historical masonry mosques. Engineering Failure Analysis, 151, 107387.
Kocaman İ, Kazaz İ (2023). Global drift ratio limits for historical masonry mosques. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 21(5), 3011–3040.
Kocaman İ (2024). Examination of the damage limits and collapse mechanism of Adıyaman Ulu Mosque with finite element model. Structures, 70, 107787.
Kocaman İ, Mercimek Ö, Gürbüz M, Erbaş Y, Anıl Ö (2024). The effect of Kahramanmaraş earthquakes on historical Malatya Yeni Mosque. Engineering Failure Analysis, 161, 108310.
Kocaman İ, Ertosun Yıldız M, Yıldız MA, Eroğlu E, Çetin S (2025). A proposal for reinforcement of historical masonry minarets: Gaziantep Kabasakal Mosque Minaret. Buildings, 15(8), 1213.
Kocaman İ, Gedik B, Okuyucu D (2025). The effects of the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes on historical masonry minarets in Hatay, Türkiye. Sādhanā, 50(3), 155.
Kocaman İ, Yazıcı C, Gürbüz M (2025). Enhancing the seismic resilience of historical masonry cupolas: a finite element study on Cimcime Hatun Cupola. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 23(14), 6339-6364.
Lourenço PB (2006). Recommendations for restoration of ancient buildings and the survival of a masonry chimney. Construction and Building Materials, 20(4), 239-251.
Mohd Nazri SI, Ariffin NF, Mohamad Borhan MF (2025). Evolutionary process and mechanical properties of polymers: a comprehensive review. Challenge Journal of Concrete Research Letters, 16(4), 225-242.
Nebioğlu OÖ, Kocaman İ (2025). Seismic behavior of historical Erzurum three Cupolas under strong ground motions. Sādhanā, 50(2), 47.
Niroula B, Bhatt MR (2026). Mechanical properties assessment of recycled brick aggregate concrete using demolition waste from century-old masonry buildings in Nepal. Challenge Journal of Concrete Research Letters, 17(1), 41-56.
Orlando M, Becattini G, Betti M (2023). Multilevel structural evaluation and rehabilitation design of an historic masonry fortress. Journal of Building Engineering, 63, 105379.
Ozcebe G, Sucuoglu H, Yucemen MS, Yakut A (2006). In defence of Zeytinburnu. In: Wasti ST, Ozcebe G, editors. Advances in Earthquake Engineering for Urban Risk Reduction. Springer, Dordrecht, Netherlands, pp. 95-116.
Razaqpur AG, Bencardino F, Rizzuti L, Spadea G (2015). FRP-RC/PC members subjected to combined actions. Challenge Journal of Structural Mechanics, 1(1), 1-8.
Requena-Garcia-Cruz MV, Romero-Sánchez E, López-Piña MP, Morales-Esteban A (2023). Preliminary structural and seismic performance assessment of the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba: the Abd al-Rahman I sector. Engineering Structures, 291, 116465.
Romero-Sánchez E, Requena-Garcia-Cruz MV, Morales-Esteban A (2024). Impact of the soil-foundation-structure interaction in the seismic behaviour of a heritage masonry tower: the Giralda of Seville. Engineering Failure Analysis, 163, 108580.
TBEC (2018). Turkish Building Earthquake Code. Disaster and Emergency Management Authority (AFAD), Ankara, Türkiye.
Trifunac MD, Brady AG (1975). A study on the duration of strong earthquake ground motion. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 65(3), 581-626.
UNESCO (2014). Anatolian Seljuks Madrasahs. https://whc.unesco.org/en/tentativelists/5907 [accessed 15-05-2023].
Usta P (2021). Assessment of seismic behavior of historic masonry minarets in Antalya, Turkey. Case Studies in Construction Materials, 15, e00665.
Ünal S, Kurt AB, Canbaz M (2025). Impact of wrap quantity on strength of damaged and undamaged CFRP-reinforced structural members. Challenge Journal of Concrete Research Letters, 16(3), 133-141.
Valente M (2021). Seismic vulnerability assessment and earthquake response of slender historical masonry bell towers in South-East Lombardia. Engineering Failure Analysis, 129, 105656.
Valente M (2022). Seismic behavior and damage assessment of two historical fortified masonry palaces with corner towers. Engineering Failure Analysis, 134, 106003.
VGM (2017). Tarihi Yapılar için Deprem Risklerinin Yönetimi Kılavuzu. General Directorate of Foundations, Ankara, Türkiye. (in Turkish)
Willam KJ, Warnke EP (1975). Constitutive model for the triaxial behavior of concrete. In: Proceedings of IABSE, Structural Engineering Report 19, Section III, pp. 1-30.
Yesilyurt A (2025). Influence of damage state threshold variability on the seismic vulnerability analysis of masonry aqueducts. Challenge Journal of Structural Mechanics, 11(3), 137-148.
Yılmaz S, Arslan M, Durmuş Demir A, Yavru TE, İmamoğlu Yılmaz E, Cebir F, Aydın Ç, Baş GY, Demir S (2025). Seismic damage assessment of historical mosques and minarets in Antakya/Türkiye after the February 6, 2023, Kahramanmaraş earthquake sequence. Engineering Failure Analysis, 182, 110125.
Zardari S, Kutlu İ, Nayeb A (2024). Investigation of structural performances of historical building elements made with local materials using the finite element method. Challenge Journal of Concrete Research Letters, 15(3), 101-111.
